Why did Human development fail to keep pace with economic development in India? [250 words][15 Marks][2023]

A. Economic Development vs. Human Development:

  • Economic development = Rise in GDP, industrial growth, infrastructure.
  • Human development = Quality of life indicators: education, health, income equity, gender empowerment (UNDP’s HDI).

India’s GDP has seen consistent growth (e.g., 7–8% average in 2000s), but HDI rank (2023) is low (134 out of 193 countries).


B. Reasons for the Mismatch:

  1. Inequality in Growth Distribution:
    • Top 10% hold ~77% of national wealth (Oxfam report).
    • Growth concentrated in urban areas & service sectors.
  2. Inadequate Public Health Infrastructure:
    • Health expenditure ~2% of GDP (below WHO recommendation of 5%).
    • Malnutrition, IMR, MMR remain high (e.g., NFHS-5: 35.5% stunted children).
  3. Education Gaps:
    • Quality issues: low learning outcomes (ASER reports).
    • Dropout rates remain high in secondary levels.
  4. Jobless Growth:
    • High youth unemployment despite GDP growth (CMIE data).
    • Informal sector dominates (over 80% of workforce).
  5. Poor Governance & Leakages:
    • Welfare schemes (e.g., MGNREGA, PDS) marred by corruption, underutilisation.
  6. Gender & Social Exclusion:
    • Low female labour force participation (~25%), caste-based barriers.

C. Conclusion:

India’s growth has not been inclusive or equity-focused. A shift from GDP-centric to people-centric policies is needed to bridge the human development gap.